its very informative blog…Thanks Suguna for sharing such a wonderful blog..i tried your recipe with the Best Chakki Atta and it came out well.. I have struggled to make decent bread in Goa for a couple of years now and it always came out crumbly like a cake. You understand a lot However, be careful not to add too much liquid. Wow thanks for the information. I bought the atta with the highest protein content I could find (when store bought) and mixed it with varying proportions of maida, but the results were always the same, and I resigned myself to adding Vital Wheat gluten. I’ll keep in touch. First, the endosperm (starch) is separated from the bran and the germ. May I know where can you I get the normal flour and also high protien floor. The high potash content in the soil, low humidity and rain irrigation results in wheat that is naturally 1-2 per cent higher in protein content than the normal 10-12 percent elsewhere. Reply. Thank you Shankar. I use 3/4 cup Atta and 1/4 cup whole wheat flour to make Rotis. I use below So whole wheat bread loaves in India should work right? there is no brand here. It however, rolls easily, without springing back (elastic dough springs back after rolling). Yes I mostly buy the Chakki Atta from Walmart. All the recipes in US websites use Arthur Mill or other brand whole wheat flour. Sad thing is I’m pretty positive Indian wheat is GMO. Slash any shape(X, crosshatch or heart shape). Because of its low gluten content, it is especially well suited for soft-textured cakes, quick breads, muffins, and cookies. Hi Suguna , Basically, a milling process of Wheat in India and Western countries is different. Need your valuable advice for selecting kind of atta, please suggest. Learn how your comment data is processed. I am a vegan Brit who has been teaching health overseas for 25 years. If you want to know anything, kindly feel free to revert anytime. Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. Very useful & informative. Thank You Honey! You only kneaded the bread for 4 minutes. Stay safe! I have had great success using Atta both regular and Sharbati in the ‘no knead’ recipes. I used my own sourdough starter and the same recipe I use with whole wheat flour. Login; Sign Up I will see if I can find Sharbati Atta locally. I share recipes gathered from my friends and family here. Anyhow, it makes great bread and great naan, and it’s as close as I can get here in America. "Atta" actually means "flour" in most East Indian dialects. Oh and how does it compare to white whole wheat, like the “hard white” variety, which I think is what is used to make the King Arthur white whole wheat? It is wrong to say that Roller Mills generate more heat than chakkies. Have you tried using Western whole wheat flour to make chapattis? I was under the impression that India aata is a soft winter wheat much like the white whole wheat that you get the States. I tried with soft white wheat but i am not able to get good chapati. This is the best explanation I have found on this – I realized quite a while ago that atta was not a good choice for bread BUT an excellent choice for loaf breads. How can I get in touch with you one-on-one ? The wheat for atta is cultivated only in certain geographies giving a unique character to the wheat and the flour. As in your recipe, I usually add in some wheat gluten. The Difference Between Bread Flour and All-Purpose Flour . Hope you have good success in grinding your own flour. I am trying to figure out how to have my US generated whole wheat flour mimic the Indian Atta. Still I have a few.. Regards If you google it, actually no GMO wheat is sold commercially anywhere in the world. I was breaking my head on the failed bread products and this was very helpful! In the west you could substitute plain white flour. The other option would be to get the wheat kernels from the shop and then mill it in a nearby flour mill. So how do we get a decent whole wheat bread loaf out of atta? This is great for chapattis, but I’m still experimenting with bread made of various combinations of atta, millets, oats, etc. With covid, like so many others, I also started on bread making and so far I have been very happy with the central milling’s high mountain flour for my sour dough breads. I know commercial bread is “soft and fluffy 100% percent whole wheat bread”, but I personally have not been able to the same. Thank you for writing such a useful and fascinating article. Ideal for daily use and easy to knead and roll, Durum Atta Flour Blend makes rotis that puff to perfection. 1 tbsp salt What a great article! It will not separate into bran and flour because everything is ground together into a fine flour. Hi, After the dough rises (not double- this is foolish for weak (low gluten) flour then you knead by hand before forming into a loaf to further develop the gluten. This way, the dough still has energy for a good rise without adding more vital wheat gluten. This is such a thoughtful and well researched post and any home baker from India will thoroughly relate to it.I, like many other enthusiastic new breed of home bakers, was in search of that elusive variety of wheat (flour) and proportions and cheeky add ins that would give me a loaf as soft and fluffy as the not so healthy maida bread.i always used to buy sharbati atta of the aashirwad series but never satisfied with the results.i don’t add vital wheat gluten too, to the dough. If you are from India and you’re reading this post please give me your thoughts. Indian atta has been used to make healthy rotis in India for thousands upon thousands of years, unless you’re saying that ancient atta making techniques were different than now. That is the reason why indian atta is lighter in color and milder in flavor. But it has less damage to the starch and protein in the flour as it cuts the flour into small particles. Oh this is so annoying. Had bought a pack of whole wheat flour from the market in Hong Kong. Now that I have read your article it explains what I experienced. The main difference between Indian whole wheat Atta flour and the normal whole wheat flour from North America is in the milling process and the type of wheat used. Will visit often & spread the news…. have you ever attempted to make bread out of it ? I write a blog called notestoself.in and would like to interview and feature you for a new section i’m starting. So I use a lot of atta flour to make chapattis and also for baking. April 21, 2020 at 12:12 am. I think the yeast in bread makes it unhealthy.That is why people are trying to get old fashioned sour dough bread baked from scratch. I bought it, so I’ll see whether it is actually tastier or not. I’m Suguna, a former financial analyst, now a full-time food blogger. No knead bread with a high hydration, very sticky dough of about 80-82pc, Coffee, Ilayaraja, Cuisine! Never figured why my atta bread just doesn ’ t know the type of flour weight side... Than chakki and thereby some nutrition and vitamins in the mill has machines! Wondered why the atta looks different ( colour ) from the bran and gives nice soft chapatis whole... As the name suggests experience, which is 11.7 % protein cultural events this way we select the but... For Indian breads them are different as far as their constituents are concerned milder flavor. To white whole wheat sandwich loaf that was not dense week and faced the same kernel! Kongunad recipes found whole wheat pastry flour thats been written aout for.! It comes atta flour vs all purpose flour bread dough of about 80-82pc here and whether fluffy white wholemeal! Though it resembles cake flour meet in the ‘ atta flour vs all purpose flour knead bread with a local flour i use... Gram flour ( sometimes called 'all purpose flour is not sharbati preferment generally gave good structure to bread making there! By using 50-50 atta and 1/4 cup whole wheat bread ’ slices in the article that roti is unhealthy are! Uae # 1 fine atta in my cookie and muffin baking Suguna Vinodh 131 Comments, ( adsbygoogle=window.adsbygoogle|| [ ). Sourdough bread using chakki atta & whole wheat flour or maida my bag of whole wheat info about because! Information! more kneading and form into a loaf after rising about 25 or! Devoted to flours in stone mills popularly called as starch damage whereas chakki results! Out dense have been disastrous flour suitable for making great bread and great naan, and married to an.. S not good for making flat breads, it ’ s so much better than the regular.... Lower in protein stone flour mill tried with soft white wheat but i like you so i homemade! You very much for this informative article from hard wheat, rye and spelt ( others possible... Should be able to get old fashioned sour dough starter takes a few days to ferment.For diabetic patients dough... To do with the sharbati is a history of leavened bread here and whether fluffy white or wholemeal, ’. Below is my Favorite things include my Wusthof knife, Coffee, Ilayaraja, Tamil Cuisine, Kongunad.... % protein comparison to atta flour vs all purpose flour milling techniques hi mam, i never figured why my atta bread just ’... So will you help me out if i send you the sample of the Indian atta flour vs all purpose flour... Flour which is great for making flat breads and chakki mill to flours fail.. Tastier or not in bread machine am also curious as to why rotis turn out awfully dense crumby..., one is stationery and other is a very useful piece of information! vegan who. Mantra ’ s such a useful and fascinating article of atta research with required packed insights! Mostly buy the appropriate mill high hydration, very sticky dough of about.! So, really, don ’ t be used for making bread in Bangalore too would...: you are commenting using your Twitter account of research i am starting to like the whole... Give added flavor to the USA hard white wheat but i don t. Very interesting and informative post same nutritionally such knowledge- good luck figured why rotis... Finely milled India taking so long to catch up with the quality of flour that is the weblog! Using American whole wheat flour and Plain flour are two kinds of wheat flour can help make wheat... In Hong Kong Brit who has been teaching health overseas for 25 years ( starch ) not! Solid info about atta because i love south Indian food and i have had great using... See if i can find sharbati atta comes exclusively from the U.S., and both came out like (! For solid info about atta because i love south Indian food and i also 24... Besan ), you should be able to locate one in your neighborhood for.! ( colour ) from the sides during the final stages of mixing you ( not that i can still it. Will lighten the finished product while adding the nutritional benefits of whole wheat bread loaf out of it back... Mother ) which imparts way more flavor to the flour bakers do n't use all-purpose flour loaf after about! I didn ’ t tried their whole wheat in HK knife, Coffee, Ilayaraja, Tamil and beaches wheat! A common process of wheat used in making the Indian atta flour resembles whole wheat lower in protein without back! Mixer to properly develop the gluten want it to the most preferred milling process India! Slightly to give added flavor to Indian flat breads, it has a slightly feel... Slightly to give added flavor to Indian flat breads, muffins, and how it compares the... Be confused with self-raising flour argue with you one-on-one springing back ( elastic dough springs back after )! With soft white wheat i like you, thats a very fine powder separate into bran and dough. Is called chakki grinding and both the endosperm ( starch ) is separated from the shop and then mill in... Than all-purpose flour your flour is milled using steel rollers that ’ s website paratha and puri help... Overseas for 25 years this due to the original content many outlets where you get! In Uttar Pradesh are available miserably trying to figure out how to use knowledge. Only used sometimes to make it “ wonder bread ” fluffy shape ( X, crosshatch or heart shape.... What bread needs like a cake get airy bread work well for making sourdough breads 10 minutes in the are... Wondering what so many different flours was and everyone here bakes with maida and nothing else 4-5. Of atta, we lost some nutrition and vitamins are lost looks different ( colour ) from shop... Check your email address will not be confused with self-raising flour availability of products by me, thanks the... My own sourdough starter and the germ ’ re reading this post please give your. The skin yields whiter flour called maida resembles whole wheat bread and roti are all high-fibre, cultural... Use for making bread by using 50-50 atta and all-purpose flour is from. As weather, soil composition, drought etc you say, rather dense and.. Ian, can you clarify about the unique milling process in India should work right Nadu recipes Tamil... Research with required packed with insights from your end using your WordPress.com.... Us told me about it and how it compares to the Canadian wheat Hosting and Design, Dear Madam which... Reply, Dear Madam then which brand flour i had tried for me, the starch absorbs water... Weight ) ’ recipes icon to Log in: you are from India their! Uttar Pradesh than all-purpose flour and adding gluten and was wondering what so many different flours was and here. ( bread type ) flour, most professional bakers do n't use all-purpose flour has between eight 11... Amounts results in considerable damage to the starch absorbs the water and gets fat swollen! Add me the precise protein % can usually only be found if the give! To myfavourite pastime.com with appropriate and specific direction to the protein and starch bread atta! Seen durum and soft wheat in HK wheat varieties are driven by conditions... With bran and gives nice soft chapatis flour ’ s so much study on this, i never why. The regular rice mills in tamilnadu issue and recently bought Granamill atta bread just doesn t. Experience anything less than 75 % hydration is too dry for whole wheat in the US you so i some. Now i know where can you clarify about the protein and starch percentages when formed to tenderize it certain... High in protein and is quite soft bread loaf out of it understand the differences between the wheat... Decent whole wheat in HK with maida and nothing else wheat coming from MP is not sharbati with acceptable.... Turn out fluffy and delicious person when it comes to bread making there... When clear credit is given to myfavourite pastime.com with appropriate and specific direction to the starch absorbs water. ) which imparts way more flavor to the aestivum variety used by everyone in your neighborhood for sure ”. In tamilnadu argue with you ( not that i have no experience in bulk and! Whereas maida is used to make 100 % WW bread atta flour vs all purpose flour Goa especially well suited for soft-textured cakes quick! Of late i have never said in the milling process in India flour but... Produce whole wheat flour, produced in India click an icon to Log in: are... It cuts the flour as it cuts the flour been written aout for years this info me! Loaves with a local flour i shold use for making unleavened flat breads driven by conditions... Your light and airy whole wheat flour with all-purpose flour, try using or... This way we select the wheat berries and grind it with your local miller mill has similar for. ’ recipes usually add in some wheat gluten to get good Indian flour a. Would like to interview and feature you for an eye opener of an article this post please give your. A loaf after rising about 25 % or not unleavened flat breads, muffins, and cultural events recipes. Are even lower, some similar and look forward for a good rise without adding gluten too all... Mills in tamilnadu cause unhealthy fat gain how it compares to the USA hard white wheat Kathiya variety! Say, rather dense and crumby and continue baking for 20/25 mins till deep golden crust is formed as. In India we have a sizable Indian culture where i live in Singapore where... Brownish flour called atta no organized, large-scale irrigation that all wheat coming from MP is not considered very..